Product Comparison

Compare Icicles No. 5 vs Mr. Hankey's Toys Seahorse

Side-by-side comparison of specifications, dimensions, charger compatibility, and discretion ratings.

Specification matrix

Specification Icicles No. 5 Mr. Hankey's Toys Seahorse
Materials Glass Silicone
Waterproof Waterproof Waterproof
Connectivity No app/remote No app/remote
Insertable Length 5+ cm 20.3+ cm
Diameter 5.1–10.2 cm
Other Features Beautiful hand-blown glass with various curves, textures, and colors. Excellent for temperature play. Hand-poured in California; highly customizable size, color, and firmness; excellent quality for large toys
Stimulation Focus Smooth glass pressure + temperature sensation Large/fullness or fantasy texture stimulation
Side-by-side indices
Index rating (1–10) No. 5 Seahorse
Satisfaction 4.5 4.5
Durability 5 5
Stealth 3.5 3
Value 4.5 4
Travel 2 2
Specs winner awards
Price Winner: Icicles No. 5 $30 vs $49.46 (cheaper by $19)
Stealth Winner: Icicles No. 5 Quieter & more compact (3.5/5 vs 3/5)
Care & charging

No. 5 — lube safety

Water-based, Silicone-based, and Oil-based safe

Non-porous glass and metal toys can be safely used with any lubricant, including oils and silicone.

No. 5 — charging

USB Charging

Standard USB charging cable

Seahorse — lube safety

Water-based lubricants only

Silicone-based or oil-based lubes will permanently degrade and ruin silicone/TPE surfaces, making them sticky and unsafe.

Seahorse — charging

USB Charging

Standard USB charging cable